Hey Cowards! -The Comments Section Isn't Your Enemy

How to handle negative online comments on your social media platforms

GOVERNMENT COMMUNICATIONS SOCIAL MEDIA

Thomas Y. Lynch

2/12/20263 min read

Social Media is the best way for Governments to have a direct line to the public. According to the Pew Research Center, more than 1/2 of US adults (59%) use social media to get their information. So when I see an organization blocking their comments page, I ask, “What are they hiding, how transparent are they, and is the information they’re presenting credible. These posts get less engagement, make the organization seem opaque, and make the communicators behind the scenes look cowardly.

So why are you running from negative comments?

Every government page gets them. You post a new program, a meeting notice, or a photo of a team, and within ten minutes someone is in the comments telling you the county is wasting their money. Sometimes they have a point. Sometimes they're just loud. Either way, everyone scrolling past is watching how you respond.

That's the part a lot of communicators forget. The person leaving the angry comment is rarely your real audience. Your audience is the hundreds of residents who read the thread and never type a word. They are quietly deciding whether your agency is honest, competent, and listening. Your reply is for them.

Here are three habits that make negative comments a lot easier to handle.

1. Answer the question, correct the record, keep it short

If a comment contains a real question, answer it, even if it's buried under sarcasm. "Why is this road closed AGAIN?" deserves a plain answer with a date. The loudest commenter is often asking what quieter residents already want to know. I wrote about this in Answer the questions people are afraid to ask out loud. Sometimes the angry person is doing you a favor by saying it first.

If a comment spreads something false, correct it once. Be calm, state the fact, and link to the source. Don't argue, and don't stack three replies under one post. Misinformation grows when nobody answers it, and it grows faster when you turn it into a fight. There's more on that in "Believe none of what you hear, and 1/2 of what you see..." and The Debunking of Conspiracy Theories.

Keep your tone the same whether the comment is polite or hostile. People notice when an agency gets defensive.

2. Take the personal stuff offline

Some complaints can't be solved in public. A missed trash pickup, how can I get substance use treatment?, or the status of an incarcerated loved. Fixing those takes an address, an account number, or a case history, and none of that belongs in a comment thread.

Reply once in public so everyone can see you responded. Something like: "Sorry about the trouble. Send us a direct message with your address and we'll get it to the right team." Then actually follow through. The public reply shows you're responsive. The private conversation is where the problem gets solved.

Think of it like public comment at a board meeting, which I covered in Your 3 Minutes is Almost Up! You listen, you acknowledge, and the real work happens afterward.

3. Write a comment policy before you need one

Hiding or deleting comments on a government page is different from doing it on your personal account. An agency page can be treated as a public forum, and courts take that seriously. In 2024 the U.S. Supreme Court ruled on when a public official's social media activity counts as government action in Lindke v. Freed. Removing a comment because you don't like the opinion can put your agency in legal trouble and in the headlines.

A written comment policy protects you. Post it where people can find it, usually in the About section of your page. Spell out what gets removed, such as threats, obscenity, spam, personal information and commercial ads. Then apply it the same way every time, whether the comment praises you or tears you apart. Have your legal counsel review it before it goes live.

I looked at the bigger picture in Free Speech on the Internet - Does it exist? For a government agency, moderation has to be about conduct, not viewpoint.

One more thing. Not every pile-on is real. Coordinated accounts can make a small complaint look like a public uprising. Before you escalate to leadership, take a minute to check whether the accounts look genuine. Read my Bot Farms - the Ultimate Social Media Influencers to find out what to look for.

The Wrap-up

Negative comments aren't going away. Treat them as free feedback. Answer what you can, move private issues to private channels, and have your rules in place before the hard day comes. The residents reading quietly will remember how you handled it.

Thomas Y. Lynch

Follow me on Social Media

“How well we communicate is not determined by how well we say things but how well we are understood.”